Gotta Play Reviews and Ratings

This web page provides user reviews and ratings for GottaPlay video game rentals. Our web site offers information about online game rentals (plus DVDs) and places to buy videogames on the internet. Browse our Gotta Play page for this web site's content on Gotta Play.

Listed first are the average ratings of GottaPlay.com based on every rating that has been submitted for GottaPlay. Continue below to browse Gotta Play reviews and individual ratings for GottaPlay videogame rentals.

Average based on 59 user ratings

Add Your Ratings for Gotta Play

See above for the average ratings for GottaPlay.com. The average ratings are a calculation based on all the feedback submitted to our site. To see individual ratings and reviews for Gotta Play continue on the remaining part of this Gotta Play review page.

Gotta Play Reviews and Ratings

21. "TOTAL SCAM, DO NOT TRY!!" Submitted on December 28, 2008

I wanted to try another game rental Service since Gamefly was taking too long to ship me games at the time (07/08). Gottaplay had the closest distribution offices to PA so I gave them a shot. After I signed up for the service, the site stated any decent or recent games where low availability. Even the games that were available took 3-5days to get from Maryland to PA. Sure they accept your returns quick, but then it takes them days to ship another one out.

After a couple months of so-so service, they suddenly do not report any of the games I sent back as received. Their customer service number is a joke. Calling them at any day/hour they state its open just goes to an automated message to e-mail customer service. I sent them DOZENS of e-mails, and not a single reply other then automated responses. I canceled my card they had on file because they were charging me for a couple months for no games and absolutely no customer service!

Now they are sending me e-mails (automated of course) stating that any games -they- lost will cost me $50 each... for old xbox1 and PS2 games that are the only games that are not low availability. Gottaplay is a joke. I'm getting the BBB and the consumerist.com involved since they are threatening to take it to a collection agency.

By Ed from PA  

22. "Riped off and looking for justice" Submitted on December 27, 2008

Like many of you I also was a customer and after renting a game it took up to 3 weeks to get it and some times longer for them to recieve it back. Then a game was lost in the mail and they claimed they didn't get it. They were going to charge me $50.00 for the game. After waiting for a month the game showed up. They sent it to anouther distribution center and didn't log it in. In the mean time they sent me more games (I was on the 2 game plan) and I decided to cancel. I was told they would have to get the games back before I canceled or I would be charged the $50.00 per game. I have been waiting now for 7 months and still they don't have the games. I have sent repeated messages about the lost games and have heard nothing from them. Calls to their phone # won't go through and now I have received an automated message that I have been sent to collections because I canceled the credit card they were billing to. I am putting together some information on this company and am thinking about a class action lawsuit against them. If you have information useful to me please send to the e-mail address provided.(wsqsa.admin@gmail.com) Please do not use this game rental company.

By Kenny from Pasco, Wa  

23. "MY GOD THIS IS A COMPANY?!?!?!?!?!?!?" Submitted on December 12, 2008

WOW, I cannot believe that this company is in business, they have NO CUSTOMER SERVICE, AND NO VALUE, they are a sham, and a fraud. I hope they are shutdown. You would think that the BBB would step in, or SOMEBODY, and close this crap organization down. I hope that NO ONE ever signs up for their service EVER!!!! BEWARE, STAY AWAY, HORRIBLE ORGANIZATION!!! THIS COMPANY IS CRAP!!!

By stack9902 from west haven, ct  

24. "DONT USE GOTTAPLAY" Submitted on December 11, 2008

It is a scam, and nothing more. They have already been prosecuted for running Pump 'n Dump scams, and are now out to steal from the people who sign up for their fraudulent service. I cancelled 2 months ago, and they are now trying to scam $150 dollars from me, for games THEY lost (or never shipped at all).

Bottom Line: AVOID GOTTAPLAY INTERACTIVE INC. AT ALL COSTS!!

By Joe from Seattle, WA  

25. "TOTAL RIP OFF!!!" Submitted on December 5, 2008

I am so pissed at Gotta Play you dont even know! I regret not looking at these reviews before signing up. I tried the free trial and everything seemed okay. However, the second I signed up i tried renting Okami. Okami never came in the mail. Unfortunately, I was nice enough to wait for two months even though I had filed complaints. So I was charged two months subscription without getting a single game. IN ADDITION, a month later they shoot me an email saying that they will charge me 50 dollars for Okami (which is greatest hits PS2 game not even worth under 30$). I tried emailing them like 5 times, none of which gotta play responded. But they are certainly good at charging your card immediantly! total rip off/scam. I tried making a case with USPS but they couldnt really do anything about it either.

DO NOT SIGN UP.
DO NOT SIGN UP.
DO NOT SIGN UP.
DO NOT SIGN UP.
DO NOT SIGN UP.

By Samson from Virginia Beach, VA  

26. "Do Not Even Attempt The Free Trial" Submitted on October 21, 2008

The games take so long the trial is over. If they don't have a game on your list available they will resend the one you just returned. They will charge you if you have a game 7 days after you cancel whether your month is up or not. Worst experience ever, I have a whole new appreciation for gamefly. BEWARE COMPANY IS TERRIBLE.

By JR from San Francisco  

27. "Horrible customer service! Ripoff service" Submitted on July 27, 2008

Do not rent from this company. Their customer service is non existant. Their shipping is so slow it is unbelievable! Their 2 games at a time is a joke and a ripoff. You get 1 at a time...if you are lucky. Go with another company. No one can possibly be as bad as Gottaplay.

By andy from milwaukee, wi  

28. "A scam operation with garbage customer service. AVOID!!!" Submitted on July 25, 2008

There was a time when Gottaplay didn't suck. They charged $1 to start a trial, which was more than enough to shy the casual gamer away. Games were always available. Even though it was more expensive than other gaming sites, they were RELIABLE as they had brand new games that I needed to review for my job.

That all changed when they went to a free trial format. Availability for any game made in the past year was gone.

Customer Service is terrible. They take between 5 and 7 business days to answer an e-mail.

Oh, and guess how long it takes them to receive a game I send to them? TEN DAYS. When you rent a game from these people, you're looking at a turnaround time of FIFTEEN TO TWENTY DAYS.

If your credit card is outdated, Gottaplay send you a notice, saying, "2nd notificiation," and threatens more charges against you. THERE WAS NO "FIRST" NOTIFICATION. Over my 2 years with gottaplay, this happened twice. They just do this so that if you have 2 games out, they can expedite the process and charge you $200 in fees.

There's also horror stories from many people when they merged with a trading site. Everyone had a balance of $0.00, but Gottaplay kept threatening them with the "Credit Card Declined 2ND NOTIFICATION" and ordered them to pay immediately. Any inquiries about why they had to pay $0.00 was met with immediate HOSTILITY. Search for "Gottaplay scam" on google and you will see the true nature of these monsters. Gottaplay has not changed their ways.

Avoid Gottaplay at all costs. I hate game rental sites now so much that I just BUY the games, play them, and then sell them off. Pretty much costs the same amount as a stupid rental after it's all said and done.

Summary: Gottaplay is overpriced, understocked, crooked, garbage staffed, CROOKED, and did I mention that they're CROOKED?

By K from USA  

29. "if u gottaplay, go away!" Submitted on June 17, 2008

short version: service sucks. all good games unavailable (long wait). shipping slow as molasses.

By fish from detroit  

30. "Gottaplay sucks!!" Submitted on June 5, 2008

When my son first started using Gottaplay in 2007 it was a good service, they even had a human being answering the phone. But now they've gone "annonymous." We were charged $50 for a game that arrived damaged, called Gottaplay to let them know immediately, no human ever answers the phone it's always an automated voicemail, you have to email them for anything and they don't even sign a name to the emails so you don't even know who's taking care of the problem. It takes days to get a reply by email and they never address the problem directly,just get the run around. After 3 emails they tell me to contact the USPS to report the lost game, it wasn't lost it was damaged. My son has to wait for weeks to get his games as they're always on a waitlist. What a waste of money, after he returns his games this month we're cancelling looking for another game rental site. No value, no games and NO CUSTOMER SERVICE!!! How do they stay in business?!

By G. Bernhard from Novato CA  

31. "Deceptive & illegal practices" Submitted on May 26, 2008

STAY AWAY!!! DO NOT rent through GottaPlay. One of the worst companies I have dealt with. There is a reason they are not profitable and bleeding money (check out the SEC filings). They will try to make money by not registering returned games and delaying shipping new games by WEEKS! Takes 2-4 weeks to get games! They have deceptive and false advertising on their website claiming "Fastest Shipping Guaranteed!" among many laughable others. They could EASILY be sued in a court of law regarding these statements but since they are worth nothing nobody is going to bother suing a worthless company.

Gottaplay should be a case study for MBA programs on how NOT to run a company. The paper their stock is printed on is worth more than the stock itself. It is only a matter of time before they go bankrupt. Good riddence!

By Dave from Seattle, WA  

32. "Dont Use this Service" Submitted on May 10, 2008

To reiterate Avoid this service at all costs!! Yes it is at a descent price but it will cost you twice as much due to slooooooooow shipping. My free trial days had run out before I received my 1st game. The recieving process is substantially slower. I returned a game to these guys 3weeks ago via cert. mail and it still has not been received. Yet they promptly bill every 30 days. Learn from my pain please do not use this service!

By H-Ball from Stockton CA 95203  

33. "Horrible. Really just ... horrible." Submitted on May 8, 2008

I signed up for Gottaplay after being informed by Gamefly that someone in my household still owed on a bill, and as such they were not going to allow me to create my own account. Absolute BS in it's own right, but not much I can personally do about it. So I moved on to Gottaplay.

I started to notice rather quickly that their selection was nice, but nearly every game I clicked on didn't have a description, screenshots, or any other information. And as it turns out, they don't even have descriptions for the games on the slips they are shipped in either. The slips themselves are also badly printed and faded out almost to the point of a blank paper, so that even if there were a description to be read, you wouldn't be able to.

Even the envelopes that the games arrive in are poor quality. I learned after the first rental that they tear right down both sides very easily, so I started to open them as gently as I possibly could. And even then, they still split wide open and I am forced to send back both game slips in whatever envelope is still in-tact and safe for entering the mail system. I'm always worried whether or not the games are going to make it back ok -- or at all.

Next on the list is that there are virtually no games in their all glorious selection *cough* that are actually for sale or trade. Which happens to be one of their biggest "Selling points" for alot of people.

But these problems aside, we get on to the bigger issue at hand: Game Availability. I currently have 25 games in my 'Gamebox,' and every last one of them is marked as "Long Wait." Which means I won't be seeing it anytime soon obviously. In fact, several of those games have been in the Gamebox for 2 months now, and are still marked Long Wait. When I select the game and choose "Who's Playing" to see how many copies they have out, it lists nobody... Even with the games that do list players, there are only 2. So apparently Gottaplay only has 2 copies of just about every one of their games. As it stands now, I can guarantee that any game I look for at this very moment and attempt adding to my list will be "Long Wait." So in reality, I am paying $20.00 a month for a "real" selection matching that of my own bookcase shelf. And even if you do luck out and actually get a copy of something sent out to you, plan on it taking nearly an entire 7 days to arrive.

I'm afraid I won't be paying that $20.00 much longer, because I have had just about enough of Gottaplay.

By Pup from US  

34. "Contact the BBB!" Submitted on April 28, 2008

I've had similar experiences with Gottaplay as others on this site. I am contacting the Better Business Bureau, and I encourage anyone else with issues similar to these to do the same. There is actually a BBB office in Gottaplay's town, so maybe they will actually do something about this.

By Greg from Dallas TX  

35. "Good Service, But Bad Availability" Submitted on April 23, 2008

Gotta Play does do well in the game delivery department, but overall, it isn't great. I live in Inglewood, and my game was shipped on Tuesday and arrived at my house Wednesday. However, most games on my queue were unavailable; there's no real point in paying for any service if it doesn't cater to you. Instead, you may want to try Gamerang, which has better availability, in my own opinion.

By Joeman16 from Inglewood, CA  

36. Rating Submitted on April 14, 2008

By Diane from Texas  

37. Rating Submitted on February 28, 2008

By koko from Pittsburgh, PA  

38. "Dont sign up with Gottaplay" Submitted on February 7, 2008

I signed up for the free trail and then waited 3-4 days and never received any games. so I canceled the account. Now they say that I owe them money and because of my refusal to pay they sent it to collections!

By Hargabyte from Portland OR  

39. "Not enogh availability" Submitted on January 14, 2008

They have a normal selection and the same price as other online renting sites but they must only have one copy of each game because I have a full queue and every game is a long wait. It has been a month since they sent me anything and at this point I'm wasting my money.

By Mr.Retardo from Fairfax, VA  

40. "Please make this known to everyone" Submitted on January 3, 2008

I am on my way to Gamefly. Gotta play is a freaking joke and a scam within its self. I am currently sending a email to people I know at two major companys and asking them to forward this to everyone they know. I signed up for this service on 12/12 and I wished i never had. I have only gotten two games. They just now recieved the one that i sent back and am I getting another game?? Nope everything on my gameque is either short wait(yea right I think someone doesnt know what short means) and Long wait. Are you freaking serious. I mean seriously I have games on there that came out in 06 and even thats short wait. Assasins Creed is one of the most popular game out and that crap is Long wait what the hell I mean seems like you would have freaking prepared for the demand considering the hype and reviews it was getting. I am canceling my service immediately they tricked me once never twice. Oh and that no refund for canceling in the middle of the month should have been my first clue that the service sucked because they had to say it up front.

By chimmichunga from austin, tx  

Add Gotta Play Review

More Gotta Play Reviews: 1 – 2 – 3 – 4

Submit a Gotta Play Review

Game Rental > GottaPlay > GottaPlay Review > Page 2

Thank you for coming to All Game Rentals for Gotta Play reviews and ratings and comparison info on video game rental services. Please tell your friends about our video game rental service site and these GottaPlay user reviews.