Game Fly Reviews and Ratings

This web page provides user reviews and ratings for GameFly game rentals. This site has information pertaining to internet game rentals (plus DVDs) and places to buy video games online. Visit the GameFly web page for this website's information on Game Fly.

Just below are the average ratings of GameFly.com calculated from all the ratings that have been submitted for this service. Scroll down to read Game Fly reviews and individual ratings for GameFly videogame rentals.

Average based on 169 user ratings

Add Your Ratings for Game Fly

Read the top of this page for the average ratings for GameFly.com. These are a calculation based on all the ratings submitted to AllGameRentals.com. For individual ratings and reviews for Game Fly continue on the remaining part of this Game Fly review page.

Game Fly Reviews and Ratings

121. "Gamefly was a ripoff" Submitted on August 4, 2007

The gamefly service SUCKS. They had a good availibility but thats about it, they lure you in with a fake $9 per month ad but after the first month it goes up to like $16. The turnaround time was 7 days for me, 6 if I shipped it Monday morning, and I only live 200 miles from their shipping depot, I can only imagine how terrible service would be for someone across the country. Even if I shipped the games back the same day I got them I could still only get 4 games per month, so the local blockbuster is a much better deal than this crappy service. The turnaround times should NOT be that long, netflix turnaround times are only about 3 days.

By Brian from Fresno, CA  

122. Rating Submitted on July 22, 2007

By funky from Indiana  

123. "Honest , Straight Review of Gamefly" Submitted on July 19, 2007

Gamefly, overall is a pretty good service. I signed up with them once when I lived in Los Angeles and had their service for about 3 months (before I moved). Shipping time overall was EXCELLENT, but only because their only distribution center at the time was in Los Angeles also (about 20 miles south of my residence). So there shouldnt have been any reason as to why it wasn't excellent. I canceled because I moved cross-country to D.C. Shipping time drastically changed, for the worse (of course). Turnaround times quickly changed from 1 day, to about 3 days. This was due to their single distribution center located in L.A. They now have a distribution center located in PA, which should speed up shipping times for those on the East coast.

Their game selection is also awesome (for the record, they do not offer MMORPGs). Any game you can think of, for the systems they support, Gamefly has it. The catch is that most of them are not available when you want to rent them. Right now, their site has been updated and tells you how available a certain game is (e.g. "Low", "Medium", "High", or just "Available") If a game is "Low" on availability, take it as their former "Short Wait" caption. If you have multiple systems you want to rent games for, you shouldnt be disappointed.

Their website is extremely easy to navigate through. Pick games, add them to your "Q" (Queue) and wait for them to be shipped. Its so easy. It will also tell you what games you have out.

By JimOnes from Washington, D.C.  

124. Rating Submitted on June 30, 2007

By Mark from Frederick, Maryland  

125. "Gamefly Rocks" Submitted on June 27, 2007

The shipping times used to be a little slow but they're doing a rapid return program with the post office now and they've just added a new distribution center on the east coast so shipping times aren't an issue anymore. I love them. I do the two game at a time plan and it is so worth it. Gamefly's the best! And you can buy the games you really want to keep from them at a discount and they send you the box and the player manuals and everything. Gamefly rocks!

By Brother Jimmy from New York  

126. Rating Submitted on June 5, 2007

By maria from Egypt  

127. "Turn Around Blues" Submitted on May 12, 2007

Games have been lost in the mail at least 4 times in the last year...postal problem? or?
Also the turn around is nearly 2 weeks if you live on the East Coast.
The support team is always nice and trusting but the waiting and the reporting gets old after a while. We are checking into other game rental sites.

By Joe from Cape Cod, Ma.  

128. Rating Submitted on May 5, 2007

129. Rating Submitted on May 5, 2007

130. Rating Submitted on May 2, 2007

131. Rating Submitted on April 16, 2007

132. "long shipping time, unsatisfactory customer service" Submitted on April 14, 2007

Turn around time for games was at least a week, sometimes longer.
After they claimed we damaged a game, they promised to return it to us. Still waiting after more than a month.

By pepper from Austin, TX  

133. Rating Submitted on April 13, 2007

134. Rating Submitted on April 2, 2007

135. "Nothing's Availible!!" Submitted on April 1, 2007

So i'v had gamefly for about 2 months now and they have a great selection, its just that nothing is actualy availible to ship. Out of my game Q of ten games, consisting of xbox360, wii, gamecube, and gba titles, only 3 are actualy availible at this time. Two of which are for game cube. What is the point of paying $25 a month for two games when you realy cant' choose wich ones you want and are forced to rent the ones that are availible. Top it all off with a realy slow turn around time(around 4 days)and gamefly just isn't worth it.

By Roadkill from Florida  

136. Rating Submitted on March 25, 2007

137. Rating Submitted on March 19, 2007

138. Rating Submitted on March 15, 2007

139. "Rip-off big time!" Submitted on March 11, 2007

I got a lame game so I sent it back the same day and still have not received another game yet 8 days later. They said they may send one out on Monday which will be a total of 10 days with no games. There is only 30 days in the month and I had one game for 1 day so far. Terrible value. They say if u ask for help more than one time it will delay you receiving a game even longer. I wish I would've tried a trial first. Buyer beware go elsewhere! I hear that gamelender has great delivery time. I am going to try them after this. It can't be any worse. I can rent a game at blockbuster for 5 and keep it a litte longer twice and save 10 bucks!

By angela field from mcminnville, oregon  

140. Rating Submitted on March 3, 2007

Add Game Fly Review

More Game Fly Reviews: 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 – 5 – 6 – 7 – 8 – 9

Submit a Game Fly Review

Game Rental > GameFly > GameFly.com Review > Page 7

Thank you for reading AllGameRentals for GameFly.com reviews and ratings and comparison info on videogame rental services. If you can, please email your friends and family about this videogame rentals site and our GameFly.com reviews.